HRW Warns Proposed UN Budget Cuts Could Undermine Afghanistan Investigative Mechanism

KABUL, AFGHANISTAN – Human Rights Watch (HRW) has warned that a United Nations budget proposal seeking to reduce the staffing and resources of the Independent Investigative Mechanism for Afghanistan could significantly undermine its ability to investigate international crimes and support efforts to hold the Taliban and other perpetrators accountable.

The organisation said the UN Advisory Committee on Administrative and Budgetary Questions (ACABQ) has recommended reducing the mechanism’s budget and workforce, raising concerns about its operational capacity and independence.

According to a report shared by Human Rights Watch, the recommendation has been submitted to the UN General Assembly’s Fifth Committee, which is responsible for considering the organisation’s administrative and budgetary matters and approving its budget.

The advisory committee has proposed eliminating seven of the mechanism’s 17 positions in 2027. The proposed cuts would affect investigators, legal officers, security personnel and administrative staff.

Human Rights Watch said the advisory committee had provided limited explanations for the proposed reductions. Among its recommendations, the committee suggested that the investigative mechanism could rely on other UN departments for certain security and administrative services rather than maintaining dedicated personnel.

Hillary Power, Human Rights Watch’s representative at the UN offices in Geneva, warned that reducing the mechanism’s budget and staffing would severely restrict its ability to fulfil its mandate.

She said the proposed cuts came despite the mechanism’s initial budget already being relatively limited compared with similar investigative bodies established for Syria and Myanmar, partly because of member states’ concerns about the UN’s financial crisis during negotiations over its establishment.

Power also warned that the recommendation to make the Afghanistan mechanism dependent on other UN departments for communications, security and administrative services could threaten its independence, which is a fundamental requirement for criminal investigations.

“The mechanism’s operational independence is intended to ensure the integrity and confidentiality of its work, and security of its staff, witnesses and victims. It is vital given the sensitive nature of its investigations and the risk of political interference,” she said.

The Human Rights Watch representative urged UN member states to reject the proposed reductions and approve the limited initial budget requested by the UN Secretary-General, noting that the General Assembly had taken similar steps in the past.

She also called on member states to respect the decision of the UN Human Rights Council and ensure that the investigative mechanism can begin its work without further delays and operate in a safe, secure and effective environment.

Human Rights Watch stressed that the proposed reductions could have consequences beyond staffing and administrative arrangements, particularly because the mechanism is expected to investigate some of the most serious violations of international law committed in Afghanistan, including crimes against women and girls.

The Independent Investigative Mechanism for Afghanistan was established by the UN Human Rights Council on October 6, 2025, through Resolution 60/2, following years of campaigning by Afghan human rights defenders, survivors of abuses and international rights organisations. The resolution was adopted without a vote.

Under its mandate, the mechanism is responsible for collecting, consolidating, preserving and analysing evidence of international crimes and the most serious violations of international law committed in Afghanistan. This includes violations against women and girls, as well as abuses committed by different parties to the conflict.

It is also tasked with preparing case files to facilitate fair and independent criminal proceedings before national, regional or international courts and tribunals with jurisdiction over the alleged crimes.

The mechanism is not a criminal court and does not have the authority to arrest or prosecute alleged perpetrators. Instead, its role is to preserve evidence, identify individuals and groups potentially responsible for international crimes and make information available to competent judicial authorities for future legal proceedings.

The establishment of the mechanism followed growing calls for international accountability over alleged war crimes, crimes against humanity and other serious violations committed in Afghanistan during decades of conflict and under Taliban rule. Human rights organisations have particularly emphasised the need to document the Taliban’s systematic restrictions on women and girls, which have been described by UN experts as potentially constituting the crime against humanity of gender persecution.

The mechanism is expected to play an important role in preserving evidence that could otherwise be lost, particularly given the absence of an independent and functioning judicial system capable of investigating serious crimes and holding powerful perpetrators accountable in Afghanistan.

The proposed budget reductions come at a critical stage in the mechanism’s establishment. In October 2026, the Human Rights Council again called for the prompt appointment of its staff and stressed the need to provide the mechanism with sufficient resources, operational freedom and logistical support to fulfil its mandate.

The proposal is now before the UN General Assembly’s Fifth Committee, and the advisory committee’s recommendation does not itself constitute a final budget decision. Member states will consider the proposed resources and recommendations as part of the 2027 budget process.

The debate comes amid wider financial difficulties facing the United Nations, which has been pursuing budget reductions and organisational reforms under its UN80 Initiative. However, Human Rights Watch and other human rights organisations argue that financial constraints should not undermine an accountability mechanism established to address decades of serious violations and provide a pathway to justice for Afghan victims.